Where The Buyer And Seller Had No Pre-exisiting Debtor-creditor Relationship The Transaction Is A…

In Johnson v. Washington, — F.3d —-, 2009 WL 446094 (4th Cir., (Va.),2009) the Plaintiff’s sold their home but continued to rent the property from the buyer and retained an option to repurchase. After falling behind on their payments they brought sued the buyer, alleging violations of the Truth in…

Read More »

Technical Violation of TILA Will Not Warrant Rescission Or Damages

In Bonney v. Washington Mut. Bank, No. 08-30087 (D. Mass., Feb. 9, 2009) the Plaintiffs obtained a debt consolidation loan from Defendant’s predecessor which was secured by their residence. In connection with that loan they were provided a Notice of Right to Cancel which did not specify the date of…

Read More »

Rescission Under TILA Requires That There Be A Consumer Credit Transaction; Thus There Was…

Following a telephone interview to gather financial information for a proposed loan, the Defendant in Weintraub v. Quicken Loans, Inc., No. 08-278 (E.D.Va., Feb. 5, 2009) provided the Plaintiffs a Deposit Agreement which required the Plaintiff to make a $500.00 deposit as part of the application for refinancing. Plaintiff paid…

Read More »

Whether The Borrower Has The Means To Tender Requires A Factual Determination That Can…

In Moore v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., 2:08cv 413 (E..D.Va., Feb. 2009) the plaintiff-mortgagor brought an action against the mortgagee seeking a declaratory judgment that the mortgagor had validly rescinded two mortgages when he served notice to rescind on the mortgagee. He also sought a finding of statutory damages based…

Read More »

Court Wants To Know Why Assignee Accepted Assignment Of Mortgage After It Was In…

A mortgage assignee commenced a foreclosure action after the assignment of a mortgage that was already in default. The Supreme Court, Kings County, New York in Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. Saint Aubin, 22 Misc.3d 1120(A) (Feb. 2009) dismissed its application to foreclose. The court said the required affidavit of…

Read More »

Overcharging For Settlement Services Gives Plaintiff Standing To Bring A RESPA Claim

There was a single question presented to the court Carter v. Welles-Bowen Realty, Inc., 07-3965 (6th Cir. Ohio, Jan. 23, 2009) and that was whether a plaintiff must allege a concrete injury, such as an overcharge, to have standing to bring a RESPA violation. The plaintiffs in Carter alleged that…

Read More »

FDCPA Does Not Prohibit A Debt Collector From Communicating With An Attorney For Another…

In Acosta v. Campbell, No. 07-10373 (11th Cir. Jan. 28, 2009), the plaintiff claimed that the defendants violated the FDCPA, specifically, 15 U.S.C. §1692c(b), by sending an allegedly confidential payoff letter to the attorneys for another one of her creditors, a defendant in her foreclosure action. Under a plain reading…

Read More »

Tennessee Supreme Court Reverses Appellate Court’s Holding That The Failure To Advise Insurer Of…

As we reported in the January 2008 newsletter, a Tennessee Appellate court held that a mortgagee’s failure to advise the hazard insurer of the commencement of foreclosure proceedings constituted an increase in hazard allowing the insurer to disclaim coverage. That decision has been mercifully overturned. In U.S. Bank, N.A. v.…

Read More »

District Court’s Split On Whether The Consumer’s Inability To Tender Rescission Proceeds Will Justify…

In three recent California District Court decisions, the courts were asked to dismiss TILA rescission actions on the ground that the consumer could not demonstrate the ability to tender. In Alcaraz v. Wachovia Mortg., FSB, 08-cv-01640 (E.D.Cal. Jan. 21, 2009), the assignee of the lender argued that the Plaintiff was…

Read More »

Where The Demand For Rescission Was Made Within Three Years But Suit For Rescission…

In Ramos v. Citimortgage, Inc., CIV. 08-02250 (E.D.Cal. Jan. 8, 2009), the consumer sent a letter to the assignee of the mortgage holder (assignee) demanding rescission of the loan which was made on September 25, 2005. The demand was based on the originator’s failure to supply the notice of the…

Read More »